South Africa’s small and medium enterprises (SMEs) operate in an increasingly complex, interconnected and exposed environment. While many business owners still associate liability insurance with physical-world risks, such as a customer slipping on a wet floor, damage caused during a job, or a faulty product, modern liability exposures extend far beyond bricks and mortar.
Digital operations, data handling, online presence, customer expectations and regulatory obligations now shape risks many SMEs have yet to fully recognise.
According to Melita Thurling, Head of SureThing at iTOO Special Risks, the shift has been profound.
“We have moved into a virtual space where aspects like data, online presence and reputation are becoming just as important, if not more important. Many small business owners haven’t realised that this shift has exposed them to liability claims that go way beyond what traditional insurance policies used to cover,” she explains.
A more complex risk environment
Historically, liability cover focused on physical harm or damage. But even hands-on businesses now face risks arising from digital interactions, advice-based services and customer expectations.
“Just because your business is physical in terms of how you provide a service, the complex world means that you could have claims coming from many different directions,” she says, adding that these include data breaches, incorrect advice, reputational harm, defamation through online content and even employment practices such as allegations of unfair discrimination.
Compounding this is a marked increase in consumer awareness. “People are far more aware of their rights as consumers, and they’re far more likely to pursue claims against a business,” Thurling notes.
While South Africa is not yet as litigious as the United States or Australia, SMEs increasingly face customers who expect accountability and are willing to escalate disputes.
Cyber risk is among the most underestimated exposures for SMEs. Many assume cyberattacks target only large organisations with vast data stores, but smaller businesses are often more vulnerable because they lack sophisticated cybersecurity.
“Small businesses are just as vulnerable, if not more vulnerable, because hackers know they don’t have effective cybersecurity, or any cybersecurity at all,” says Thurling.
Cyber experts continue to see rising incidents among SMEs, from data breaches to ransomware attacks, often resulting in financial loss, breach of data claims, regulatory scrutiny and reputational damage.
Misconceptions that leave SMEs exposed
Thurling highlights a common misconception among SMEs that a basic public liability policy, perhaps with a small extension for products or employment liability, is sufficient.
“They assume that basic cover is enough, and have a false sense of security when aspects like reputational harm, online exposures, data breaches and POPIA-related risks are not covered – or are covered in a very limited way,” she explains.
Even when SMEs believe they have adequate cover, gaps can emerge because owners are too busy to interrogate policies or fully disclose their activities. “Small businesses often don’t have the resources or expertise to make sure they’ve got all the cover they need. They’re running full steam just to keep the business going,” Thurling notes.
This is why specialist insurers have developed comprehensive liability solutions to plug gaps SMEs frequently overlook. Like SureThing underwritten by iTOO on behalf of Hollard.
“These policies provide all the covers they need in one accessible, affordable package. It gives small businesses the same kind of protection that big businesses have, without requiring them to pick and choose or anticipate every possible exposure,” says Thurling.
These solutions typically cover professional indemnity, cyber incidents, reputational management, POPIA-related legal assistance, defective workmanship and other areas where SMEs increasingly face claims.
Having the right insurance
When reviewing liability cover, SMEs should focus less on having insurance than on having the right insurance. Thurling advises owners to ask brokers detailed questions about risks linked to their activities, data handling, advice-based services and legal defence costs.
“The better solution is to help the broker understand your activities as deeply and widely as possible. Often descriptions are very brief, and the broker doesn’t realise there’s a component of the business that needs additional cover, and that’s exactly where the claim arises,” she says.
Thurling believes SMEs can be more proactive, especially around cyber, data protection and reputation management. “These are areas that are quite new, and businesses can benefit enormously from having the right liability policy,” she says.
As SMEs continue to navigate an increasingly complex operating environment, it is clear that liability cover can no longer simply relate to the business premises only. It must evolve alongside the risks businesses face, and the right policy can make all the difference between resilience and vulnerability.

